Hobart and Tasmanian Business Valuation Questions: 65 Plain Answers
Written for owners, directors, accountants and lawyers in Hobart, Glenorchy, Clarence, Kingborough, the Huon Valley and the rest of Tasmania. Pick a topic below, or read from the basics through to the specialist points that arise in Supreme Court of Tasmania disputes, ATO reviews, State Revenue Office matters and business sales.
Disclaimer: Information on this site is general only and not professional advice. InteleK Business Valuations & Advisory Pty Ltd makes no warranties regarding accuracy. Use is subject to our website Terms and Conditions.
1
Fundamentals of Business Valuation
Start here: what a valuation is, what the law means by market value, how long the work takes and which events in the life of a Tasmanian business call for one.
A business valuation is a certified valuer's written opinion of what a business, or an interest in it such as a parcel of shares or trust units, is worth at a stated date. The valuer works through several years of accounts, adjusts them for private and one-off items, looks at the industry and at trading conditions in Tasmania, assesses the risks to future profit and applies one or more accepted methods. The answer is usually a range with a preferred figure. A Moonah engineering workshop, a Salamanca Place restaurant and a Huon Valley orchard need different evidence, yet each figure is only as reliable as the reasoning set out behind it.
Write it on the assumption that someone will try to pull it apart: an ATO case officer, the other side's expert, or a judge of the Supreme Court of Tasmania or the Federal Circuit and Family Court in Hobart. A report survives that reading when a qualified certified valuer signs it, it follows APES 225 and the International Valuation Standards, and it tests the income, market and asset approaches before saying why one leads. Every assumption and data source is disclosed so another professional could rebuild the figure, and a second valuer reviews the file before release. In the Supreme Court it must also meet Part 19 of the Supreme Court Rules 2000 and the Expert Witness Code of Conduct.
That depends on the report you need and on how quickly the information arrives. Indicative, Summary and Detailed reports are delivered from seven business days after receipt of all information. A Detailed report for a Supreme Court of Tasmania proceeding or a contested property settlement usually runs longer, because it carries more analysis, the expert evidence requirements and an internal review before it is signed. An Indicative report is intended for internal decision-making and is not a certified opinion for lenders, courts or the ATO. The part you control is the document pack: when the accounts, tax returns, leases and shareholders' agreement arrive together at the start, the timetable holds.
Market value is the price a hypothetical willing buyer and willing seller would settle on, both properly informed, neither under pressure and dealing at arm's length. The test comes from the High Court's 1907 decision in Spencer v Commonwealth, and the ATO's market valuation guidelines build on it for CGT events, the market value substitution rule in section 116-30 of the ITAA 1997, deceased estates and Division 83A share scheme grants. Where a Tasmanian deal involves land or a land-holding entity, the State Revenue Office of Tasmania assesses transfer duty or landholder duty under the Duties Act 2001 (Tas) and expects the values behind it to be supportable. Financial statements use a different yardstick: fair value under AASB 13, an exit price between market participants.
Not always, and the title on the cover tells you less than the work inside. APES 225 and the International Valuation Standards set out what a valuation involves, and the professional bodies hold their members to it. A business broker's listing guide, a lender's desktop number or the output of an online calculator is an estimate: useful as a starting point, but prepared without the normalised accounts, risk analysis and documented reasoning a valuation requires. If a Hobart bank, the ATO, the State Revenue Office of Tasmania or a court has to rely on the figure, ask for a report signed by a certified valuer that shows its method and its evidence.
Most Tasmanian owners first need one at a turning point: a sale or purchase, a merger, a restructure or rollover, a transfer between related parties (where section 116-30 of the ITAA 1997 substitutes market value), the administration of a deceased estate, a property settlement in the Federal Circuit and Family Court in Hobart, a dispute between shareholders or partners, an SMSF transaction, a new bank facility or a Division 83A share grant. In a state where so many businesses are family owned, handing over to the next generation is often the trigger. Between those events, a fresh figure every two or three years, or after a big contract, acquisition or loss, keeps decisions grounded in current numbers.
2
Why and When a Valuation Is Needed
Tasmania had 45,094 actively trading businesses at 30 June 2026, a net increase of 850 over the year (Source: ABS, Counts of Australian Businesses, July 2022 to June 2026, released 18 August 2026). Sooner or later each one meets a sale, an estate, a separation, a tax event or a falling-out between co-owners; this section covers what each occasion expects from the report.
Without one, a sale is a negotiation with no fixed point. As the seller, a certified report shows the price your earnings support and lets you explain to a buyer how it was reached. As the buyer, it tests whether the asking price for a Cambridge fabrication shop or a North Hobart cafe rests on profit that will last. One report can also support the finance application, record market value for CGT and the small business concessions, and serve as a record made at the time if a warranty or earn-out dispute arises. For buyers, the diligence behind the figure often matters most, because it finds weak points in the accounts before settlement, not after.
Australia has no death duty or gift duty, but moving a business to a family trust, to the next generation or between related entities is still a CGT event, and section 116-30 of the ITAA 1997 uses market value in place of the price where the parties are not dealing at arm's length. Assets that pass on death generally carry the deceased's cost base across under section 128-15. Executors, whether family members or the Public Trustee, still need a date-of-death figure for the estate accounts, for CGT when beneficiaries later sell, and for any claim under the Testator's Family Maintenance Act 1912 (Tas), which the Supreme Court of Tasmania hears. Where a minority parcel is involved, the valuation also supports any discount for lack of control or marketability.
Yes, whenever a business, shares in a private company or units in a trading trust form part of the asset pool. The Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia hears Tasmanian matters at its registries in Hobart and Launceston, and it expects the figure to come from a qualified certified valuer whose report meets APES 225 and the court's expert evidence rules. The valuer adjusts the accounts for drawings, related-party rent and personal spending, considers each relevant approach and states a clear value at the relevant date. Most separating couples agree on a single expert. If they cannot, the court may permit a second expert and direct the two to confer and narrow the issues.
The ATO expects a market valuation whenever a tax outcome depends on what a business or a parcel of shares is worth. Common examples are CGT events, related-party transfers not at arm's length, the maximum net asset value test for the small business CGT concessions, Division 7A loans and asset transfers, SMSF acquisitions of unlisted shares or business real property, and Division 83A share scheme grants. ATO guidance expects a suitably qualified valuer, a recognised method and working clear enough for a reviewer to retrace. State taxes run separately: where land or a land-holding entity changes hands, the State Revenue Office of Tasmania assesses transfer duty or landholder duty under the Duties Act 2001 (Tas), and a well-supported valuation helps if the values are questioned.
That turns on why you needed it. A valuation obtained in the course of earning assessable income or running the business, such as one supporting a sale, a lender's request or a restructure, is often deductible or forms part of the cost base of the asset concerned. A valuation for private reasons, for example dividing property after a separation, usually is not. Because the answer follows the purpose and character of the expense under income tax law, your accountant or tax adviser should make the call, not the valuer. To help them, our engagement letter states the purpose of the valuation clearly.
Usually, yes. Disputes between co-owners tend to end as an argument over the price of one party's interest, and without a neutral figure each side anchors to its own number. A certified valuation gives mediation, negotiation or the court a shared starting point. Oppression claims under the Corporations Act are brought in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, where corporations matters run under the Supreme Court (Corporations) Rules 2008, or in the Federal Court at its Tasmania registry in Hobart. Partnership dissolutions fall under the Partnership Act 1891 (Tas). Expert reports in the Supreme Court must comply with Part 19 of the Supreme Court Rules 2000. Check your shareholders' agreement first, as it may already set a valuation formula, a valuer or a trigger.
3
Approaches and Methods
The income, market and asset approaches, the techniques that sit under each, and how the valuer decides which one should carry the figure for your business.
Valuers group every recognised method into three approaches. The income approach looks forward to the profit or cash the business should generate, using either capitalisation of maintainable earnings or a discounted cash flow. The market approach relies on prices paid for comparable businesses, or on the trading multiples of listed companies, applied to revenue, EBITDA or the owner's discretionary earnings. The asset approach restates what the business owns and owes at current values and nets one against the other. A certified valuer considers all three, chooses the one that fits the business and the purpose, and uses the others as a check, so the answer never hangs on one line of reasoning.
A DCF values the business as the cash it will produce, expressed in today's dollars. The valuer forecasts free cash flow over a set period, often five years, chooses a discount rate that reflects the risk of falling short of that forecast, and estimates a terminal value for the years beyond it. Each amount is discounted back to the valuation date and the results are added. The method suits businesses whose forecasts can be tested against contracts or a clear plan, such as a marine engineering firm with multi-year work supporting Antarctic and Southern Ocean operations out of Hobart. For a small owner-run business with no dependable forecast, a DCF is usually a cross-check rather than the lead.
This method takes one sustainable level of earnings and converts it into value with a capitalisation rate, which is arithmetically the same as applying a multiple. It assumes normalised profit will continue at roughly today's level, so it suits established businesses with a steady record, such as a long-running Sandy Bay physiotherapy clinic or a Glenorchy electrical contractor with a loyal base of repeat customers. To get the capitalisation rate, the valuer takes the return a buyer would require and subtracts the long-term growth they could expect. Most of the judgement goes into the earnings figure: which years are representative, which adjustments are justified, and whether recent results will hold.
The market approach starts from evidence of what buyers have paid: prices for comparable private businesses, or the multiples at which similar listed companies trade. The usual measures are enterprise value to revenue, enterprise value to EBITDA, and price to earnings. The valuer selects a peer group, works out its multiples, then adjusts for differences in size, growth, margin, customer spread and risk before applying the result to the subject's normalised earnings. Tasmania is a small market, so local sales evidence is often thin and needs care. A listed national engineering group tells you little on its own about a three-person drafting practice in the Hobart CBD, and the report has to explain how that gap was bridged.
When the value sits in what the business owns rather than in what it earns. That covers investment and property-holding entities, businesses winding down or earning less than a fair return on their capital, and equipment-heavy operators whose profit does not exceed the value of their plant and land, such as a quarry and haulage business in the Derwent Valley or a cold-storage operator at Cambridge. Each asset and liability is restated to market value, often with help from plant and property valuers, and liabilities are deducted to reach net asset value. For a profitable service business the asset approach sets a floor, not the answer.
EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation) is struck after paying a market salary to whoever runs the business, as if a hired manager did the work. SDE (seller's discretionary earnings) adds back the working owner's wage and personal benefits, because the buyer of a single-site North Hobart cafe or an owner-driver delivery round plans to do that job and take that income. SDE is always the larger number, so the multiples applied to it are smaller. The mistake we see most often in owners' own estimates is an EBITDA multiple applied to SDE, which inflates the value every time.
4
Advanced Valuation Concepts
The working behind the number: enterprise and equity value, normalised profit, WACC, goodwill and how a private company's discount rate is built.
Enterprise value is what the operations are worth, whatever mix of debt and equity funds them. Equity value is what is left for the owners once borrowings and other prior claims are paid. To move from one to the other, start with enterprise value, deduct net debt, then adjust for any working capital shortfall or surplus. Most buyers agree a headline enterprise value and convert it to an equity price at completion by counting cash, debt and working capital on the day. That is why the owner of a Moonah engineering workshop can receive a noticeably different sum at settlement from the price agreed at the handshake.
Normalisation restates past results to the profit a new owner, dealing at arm's length, could expect to earn. Typical adjustments remove one-off items such as flood or storm damage, a legal settlement or a large bad debt; reset the wages of owners and family members to market rates; strip out private costs run through the business; bring rent to market where a related party owns the premises, for example a Cambridge warehouse held in the family trust; separate surplus assets and the income they produce; and apply accounting policies consistently across the years reviewed. Without these steps, any multiple is applied to a profit no buyer would actually receive.
WACC is the blended return required by everyone who funds the business, shareholders and lenders alike, with each source weighted by its share of the capital. In a DCF of the whole enterprise, it is the rate used to discount free cash flow. The formula is simple to state: weight the cost of equity by equity's share of the funding, weight the after-tax cost of debt by debt's share, and add the two. Debt costs less and is easy to observe; equity costs more and needs more support. A higher WACC builds in more risk, so each future dollar adds less to value today.
Goodwill is the amount left when the market value of identifiable net assets, tangible and intangible, is subtracted from the value of the whole business. It captures reputation, client and referral relationships, a capable team, location and systems: whatever lets the business earn more than a basic return on its assets. The valuer usually values the business on an income or market approach, values the identifiable net assets, and treats the gap as goodwill. The harder question is who owns it. For a Bellerive optometry practice built around one principal, deciding how much goodwill is personal and how much would transfer can settle a sale price or a family law outcome.
The build-up method assembles the return an investor would need from a private company's shares, one layer at a time. It starts with a risk-free rate, usually taken from Australian Government bond yields, then adds an equity risk premium for holding shares rather than bonds, a size premium because smaller firms are riskier, an industry premium where the sector warrants it, and a specific premium for the subject's own exposures: one dominant client, dependence on the founder, a short lease, or reliance on freight across Bass Strait. Because it needs no beta, which cannot be observed for an unlisted company, it is the usual tool for private Tasmanian businesses.
5
Discounts and Premiums
Minority, marketability and key person adjustments: what each one measures, where the evidence comes from and how they combine without double counting.
A discount for lack of marketability reflects the fact that shares in a private company cannot be sold quickly on an exchange. There is no ready market, the constitution or shareholders' agreement often limits transfers, finding a buyer takes time and money, and the eventual price is uncertain. A minority holding carries a larger discount than a controlling one, because a controller can at least sell the whole business. To size it, the valuer draws on studies of discounts on shares that could not be freely traded, pre-IPO pricing research and option-based models, then fits it to the facts: the dividend record, the prospects of a sale, and any put options or drag-along and tag-along rights.
A discount for lack of control, often called a minority discount, prices in what a non-controlling holder cannot do: set strategy, appoint or remove directors, fix their own pay, declare dividends, or force a sale or winding up. A buyer of that kind of stake pays less per share than a buyer acquiring control. Valuers usually derive the discount from control premiums seen in takeovers of listed companies, because the two measure the same gap from opposite sides: the discount equals the premium divided by one plus the premium. Its size depends on the shareholders' agreement and on whether the minority holder has real protections, such as veto rights or a put option.
A control premium is what a buyer pays above the pro rata value of the shares to take control of the company. Control brings the power to set direction, use the cash, appoint and pay management, decide dividends and, in the end, sell or wind up the business. Premiums are measured from listed company takeovers by comparing the offer price with the share price before the bid was announced, and they vary with the sector, the size of the target and the circumstances of the deal, such as whether a rival bidder emerged. In private company work the premium is mostly used in reverse, to estimate the minority discount on a non-controlling parcel.
Yes. A minority holding in a private company usually has both problems at once: the holder can neither direct the company nor sell easily. The two discounts are applied in sequence rather than added together. Take an illustrative controlling, marketable value of 100. A 15 per cent minority discount brings it to 85, and a 30 per cent marketability discount on that brings it to 59.5, not the 55 that adding the percentages would suggest. The valuer also has to avoid counting the same risk twice, because some features, such as a tight transfer clause in the constitution, reduce both control and marketability.
A key person discount reflects the risk that profit, clients or know-how would leave with one individual: the founder of a North Hobart design studio who holds every major account, the winemaker whose name sells a small Tasmanian label, or the estimator behind every tender a Kingston builder wins. Rather than applying a standard percentage, the valuer estimates how much of the earnings would go with that person and how long a replacement would take to settle in, then either reduces maintainable earnings or lifts the company-specific risk premium. It is common in practices and founder-led firms, and it shrinks as management depth, written processes and shared client relationships improve.
6
Industry-Specific Questions
How the method changes for Salamanca and waterfront venues, Hobart health practices, Tasmanian manufacturers and food producers, professional firms and businesses that rely on one big customer.
Most venues are valued on normalised EBITDA, or on the owner's discretionary earnings where the owner works the floor, with revenue multiples as a sense check. The lease weighs as heavily as the trading: a Salamanca Place restaurant with two years left and no option is worth far less than one with a fresh term, and the valuer reads the lease against the Fair Trading (Code of Practice for Retail Tenancies) Regulations 1998 (Tas) where they apply. Covers, spend per head, food and wage ratios, the licence under the Liquor Licensing Act 1990 (Tas) and the life left in the fit-out are all tested. Because Hobart trade swings between the summer peak and the winter festival season, a full year of figures counts for more than one strong quarter.
A practice is worth the profit left once every clinician, the owner included, is paid a market rate for clinical work, because that surplus is what a buyer actually acquires. Steady demand, Medicare and Ahpra regulation and long patient relationships support value, but the valuer tests how much goodwill belongs personally to the principal, especially in a single-doctor clinic. Other inputs are the billing mix of bulk-billed, privately billed and gap fees, practitioner agreements and their terms, and the payroll tax position of any service-fee arrangements under the Payroll Tax Act 2008 (Tas). Comparables come from similar practices, whether specialist rooms near the Royal Hobart Hospital or GP clinics in Glenorchy, Kingston and Rosny Park.
Earnings lead the valuation of a manufacturer, and the plant and equipment act as the check. The valuer applies a multiple or a DCF to normalised EBITDA, then compares the result with the net value of machinery, stock and property, because buyers rarely pay much above asset value unless profit supports it. In Tasmania the questions include spare capacity, reliance on a few customers, the age of the equipment and the spending needed to keep it running, the cost and reliability of freight across Bass Strait, the workers compensation claims record, and whether sales come from contracts or one-off orders. For seafood and food processors, the supply relationship with the salmon or horticulture sector is often the largest single risk.
Professional firms depend on people who can walk out the door, so the valuer tests what would survive a change of ownership. The method capitalises maintainable earnings after paying every principal a market salary, then looks at client retention, the share of recurring work, fee concentration, restraint clauses and the depth of the next layer of staff. A Hobart CBD firm with institutional clients and a clear path to partnership earns a higher multiple of profit than a sole practitioner in Kingston whose clients follow one person. Rules of thumb based on fees are a cross-check at most, never the basis of the opinion.
A great deal. If one client provides a big share of sales, its departure would take a big share of profit too, and buyers price that risk by paying less per dollar of earnings. As a working guide, valuers start asking questions once a single customer accounts for more than about a tenth of revenue, or the five largest for more than half. A marine services business that earns most of its income from one aquaculture company, or a contractor tied to a single government agency, are familiar Tasmanian examples. Long contracts, high switching costs, a diversifying trend and a long relationship all ease the concern. If one account dominates, the valuer may run a scenario in which it is lost and weight that outcome against one in which trading continues.
7
SaaS & Technology Valuations
Subscription revenue, retention and the balance between growth and profit: how software and technology companies are valued from idea stage to steady earnings.
A software company in growth mode usually spends its margin on growth, so its profit understates its worth and valuers anchor on recurring revenue instead. Annual recurring revenue is the base, and the multiple rises with growth, gross margin, retention and the reliability of renewals. Investors also look at unit economics, comparing customer lifetime value with the cost of winning a customer, together with churn, net revenue retention and contract length. Once growth slows and profit appears, a SaaS business is valued on earnings like any other. For Hobart founders, whose companies are often small and closely held, the best evidence is usually a priced funding round or a trade sale of a comparable platform.
The Rule of 40 is a quick test of whether a software company balances growth with profit. Add the annual revenue growth rate to the EBITDA or free cash flow margin; a total of 40 or more is generally read as healthy. As an illustration, 30 per cent growth with a 15 per cent margin scores 45 and passes, while 10 per cent growth with a 5 per cent margin scores 15 and fails. The test is popular because it rewards either fast growth or strong margins and exposes businesses that offer neither. Companies above the line tend to attract higher revenue multiples, so the score helps place the subject among its peers.
Monthly recurring revenue is the subscription income a company expects to bill in a month from its existing customers; annual recurring revenue is that monthly figure multiplied by twelve. Implementation fees, consulting work and other one-off income are left out of both. Valuers and investors focus on ARR because it shows the contracted base on an annual footing. The movement inside the number matters as much as the total: new customers, expansion from upgrades, contraction from downgrades and revenue lost to churn are tracked separately, so the valuer can see whether growth comes from a healthy base or from heavy spending to replace customers who leave.
Net revenue retention compares what a group of customers pays now with what the same group paid a year earlier, counting upgrades, downgrades and cancellations but leaving out new customers. A result of 110 per cent means that group now pays 10 per cent more; 90 per cent means the company has to win new customers just to stand still. Anything above 100 per cent means the business grows even if it signs no one new, and investors read that as proof that customers value the product and accept its pricing. It feeds straight into the multiple, because a dollar of ARR in a high-retention business compounds over time, while the same dollar in a leaky one wears away.
With no revenue or profit, earnings-based methods do not work, so the valuer turns to techniques built for early-stage companies. The venture capital method starts from a realistic exit value and works back using the return an investor would demand. Scorecard and Berkus-style methods assign value to milestones reached, such as a working product, a strong team or proven demand. A DCF is possible, but its discount rate must reflect a high chance of failure. A recent priced round is the best evidence there is. For a Hobart start-up commercialising marine or Antarctic research, much of the value rests on its intellectual property, its rights to use that research, regulatory progress and the founders' record.
8
Credentials and Standards
Who should sign your report, the standards it must meet, and what to ask before you engage a valuer for a Tasmanian business.
The best signatory pairs a valuation-specific credential with a financial qualification. The CBV (Certified Business Valuer) designation covers business valuation alone; holders need a relevant degree and peer-reviewed valuation experience, and must keep up their professional development. A Chartered Accountants ANZ (CA) or CPA Australia (CPA) membership adds accounting depth and obliges the member to follow APES 225 whenever they value a business. CFA signals depth in markets and discount rates, ABV is recognised internationally, and FAVI identifies a senior member of the Australian Valuers Institute. Whatever the letters after the name, the Supreme Court of Tasmania and the ATO will measure the report against APES 225 and the International Valuation Standards.
The difference is focus. CBV is a business valuation credential and nothing else, earned through tertiary study, peer-reviewed engagements and continuing education in valuation. CA and CPA are accounting qualifications: members of either body who value a business must follow APES 225, and many go on to further valuation study, but the designation alone does not test valuation skill. The strongest signature on an Australian valuation report belongs to someone who holds CBV together with CA or CPA, so method, financial analysis and professional obligations sit with one person.
The main standard is APES 225 Valuation Services, issued by the Accounting Professional and Ethical Standards Board and binding on members of CA ANZ, CPA Australia and the IPA, with APES GN 20 guiding scope of work. The International Valuation Standards provide the global framework. For takeovers and schemes of arrangement, ASIC Regulatory Guides 111 and 112 set out what an expert's report must contain and how far its author must stand apart from the parties. Financial reporting valuations follow AASB standards, chiefly AASB 2, 3, 13 and 136. In the Supreme Court of Tasmania an expert must also comply with Part 19 of the Supreme Court Rules 2000 and the Expert Witness Code of Conduct attached to Practice Direction No 1 of 2016, and the Evidence Act 2001 (Tas) governs how opinion evidence is admitted.
First find out who will sign the report and what they hold (CBV, CA, CPA, CFA or ABV), and whether they have done this kind of valuation, for this purpose, before. A property settlement report for the Hobart registry is a different job from a Division 83A valuation for a software start-up. Confirm the report will meet APES 225 and IVS and that the valuer will give evidence if required. If your business is outside Hobart, from the Huon Valley to the north-west of the state, ask how they will work with you by video call and phone. Be wary of anyone who names a figure before seeing the accounts.
9
The Engagement Process and Your Documents
From the first call to the signed report: what happens at each step, the documents to collect and the three engagement types APES 225 recognises.
It starts with a call to confirm why you need the valuation, which interest is being valued and at what date. APES 225 then requires the terms of engagement in writing, covering scope, standard of value and deliverables, before work begins. You send the financial and legal documents, and the valuer interviews management, usually by video call. The analysis covers the economy, Tasmanian conditions in your industry and the business itself, then normalisation, the selected approaches and reconciliation to a final figure. An internal reviewer checks the draft, you confirm the facts are right, and the certified valuer signs and issues the report.
Have three to five years of financial statements ready, plus year-to-date management accounts, the matching tax returns, any budget or forecast, the constitution or partnership deed, the shareholders' agreement and any buy-sell terms, an asset register and stock report, premises leases, loan agreements and covenants, revenue by customer and short profiles of key staff. Depending on the industry we may also ask for workers compensation records, occupational licences issued through Consumer Affairs Tasmania, liquor or gaming approvals, and major customer or supplier contracts. A complete pack at the outset shortens the timetable and sharpens the analysis.
The engagement letter is the agreement between you and the valuer, and APES 225 requires its terms to be agreed in writing before work starts. Inside it you will find the purpose, the interest to be valued, the valuation date, the standard of value (market value, or fair value under AASB 13 for financial reporting), the scope and applicable standards, the report type, the timetable and the fee. It also names who may rely on the report, which matters when it is going to a lender, the ATO or the Supreme Court of Tasmania. Settling these points first avoids the problem we see most: a report that answers a different question from the one the client needed answered.
APES 225, read with APES GN 20, recognises three kinds of engagement. A full Valuation Engagement lets the certified valuer use whichever approaches and methods suit the task and state an opinion of value; it is the most complete form. A Limited Scope Valuation Engagement narrows the work in a way the report discloses, for example fewer approaches, limited information or a narrower audience. In the third type, the valuer applies only procedures agreed with the client in advance, often a single method, and reports a calculated value rather than a full opinion. Our Indicative, Summary and Detailed reports follow a similar scale. An Indicative report is intended for internal decision-making and is not a certified opinion for lenders, courts or the ATO.
The interview supplies what the financial statements cannot. Over an hour or two, usually by video call, the valuer talks with the owner or senior team about how the business started, what it sells and to whom, how it competes, which staff are critical and what would happen without them, where revenue is concentrated, what capital spending is coming, any disputes or regulatory issues, and how much depends on the owner. For Tasmanian businesses it often covers seasonality and freight as well. Those answers drive the normalisation adjustments, the risk premium and the choice of method, and many owners find it the most useful hour of the engagement because it shows them the business as a buyer would see it.
10
Employee Share Scheme (ESS) Valuations
Valuing shares, options and rights issued to staff under Division 83A: when a figure is needed, how often to update it and where companies go wrong.
Under an employee share scheme, a company issues its own shares, options or rights to staff, often below market value or at no cost. Division 83A of the ITAA 1997 taxes that discount, so the company has to establish the market value of the interests at grant or at a later taxing point, and a private company has no share price to point to. A valuation fills the gap. Eligible start-ups can use the concessions in Subdivision 83A-E and the ATO-approved safe harbour valuation methods, including a net tangible assets method, which lower cost and risk. Hobart technology, marine science and agritech companies use these schemes to attract and keep specialist staff.
Division 83A requires a value at each ESS taxing point: the grant date for schemes taxed upfront, or a later point such as vesting for tax-deferred schemes. Each new issue usually needs a current valuation unless nothing material has changed, and start-ups relying on the Subdivision 83A-E safe harbours often refresh at every grant round. A capital raising, an acquisition, a major contract won or lost, or any other event that could move value should prompt an update, because an outdated figure can leave employees with a tax shortfall and the company with a reporting problem.
Independence comes first: the valuer must have no stake in the company or in the outcome. The method must be one the ATO accepts or, for eligible start-ups, one of the approved safe harbour methods under Subdivision 83A-E, and the file must be documented well enough to survive an ATO review years later. The employer also has to lodge an annual ESS report with the ATO and give each participant a statement. If an offer needs disclosure, the employee share scheme and fundraising provisions of the Corporations Act apply, and where scheme shares end up in an SMSF, the SIS Act rules on in-house assets and related parties add another layer.
The plan rules decide. A departing employee usually keeps vested shares, while unvested shares, options and rights lapse or are forfeited. Under tax-deferred schemes, leaving a job used to be a taxing point in itself, which meant a market valuation at the departure date; that rule no longer applies to newer grants, so ask your adviser how your plan is treated. If the plan or constitution allows the company to buy back the departing employee's shares, the buy-back must comply with Part 2J.1 of the Corporations Act, and a valuation at the buy-back date supports a defensible price.
11
Technical and Modelling Questions
How a DCF is put together and tested, why terminal value carries so much weight, and how to value earnings that move with the seasons or the economic cycle.
Building one begins with the history: three to five years of normalised results that reveal how revenue, margins and working capital behave. Revenue is then projected from that record, management's plans and market conditions, and costs, capital spending and working capital movements are modelled to give free cash flow for each forecast year, usually five. After the forecast, a terminal value is set either by growing the last year's cash flow at a steady rate forever or by applying an exit multiple. Enterprise cash flows are discounted at WACC; if the shares themselves are being valued, the cost of equity is used instead. Every cash flow and the terminal value are discounted to the valuation date and added together.
A sensitivity table answers a simple question: how much does the value change if one assumption turns out differently? The valuer shifts the discount rate, revenue growth, margin, terminal growth or the multiple, one at a time and together, and sets out the results, often as a table. Readers can then see which inputs drive the result and how wide the reasonable range is, rather than treating one figure as exact. It also disciplines the valuer: if a small change in the discount rate moves value a long way, that input needs especially careful support. In a Supreme Court of Tasmania proceeding, the sensitivity table is usually where the opposing expert begins.
Terminal value captures everything the business earns after the forecast period, and it is often the larger part of a DCF result. There are two ways to calculate it. The perpetuity growth method takes the final forecast cash flow, grows it by one year at the long-term rate and divides by the discount rate less that growth rate. The exit multiple method instead multiplies the final year's EBITDA or revenue by a market-derived multiple. Long-term growth should not exceed the economy's long-run rate, and an exit multiple has to be consistent with the discount rate. Because so much rests on these choices, reviewers look at them first.
The valuation should reflect a typical year across the whole cycle, not the peak or the trough. The valuer reviews a longer history covering at least one full cycle, weights the years to reach mid-cycle maintainable earnings, and may build a scenario DCF with upturn, base and downturn cases weighted by probability. The discount rate rises with volatility, and the asset approach acts as a floor. Tasmania offers plenty of examples: a tourism operator whose year depends on the summer peak and the winter festival season, or a civil contractor enjoying a run of work linked to Macquarie Point, cannot assume the good years will last, and the valuation should not assume it either.
12
Practical and Strategic Questions
Preparing for a sale, the gap between value and price, keeping a valuation current and your options if you think the figure is wrong.
Start with the issues a buyer would use to argue the price down. Reduce your reliance on any one customer. Move one-off work onto contracts or recurring arrangements. Document how the business operates and train managers who can keep it running in your absence. Tidy the accounts by removing private costs, settling disputes and bringing the balance sheet up to date. Lock in a long lease with options and put key supplier terms in writing. Keep plant maintained so a buyer does not inherit a capital bill. Show growth, not a plateau. In a market the size of Tasmania's, where the pool of buyers for any one business can be thin, these steps count for more, and most take two to three years to show in the results.
Value is an opinion: what a hypothetical buyer should pay, judged from the business's cash flow, assets, risks and outlook. Price is what a particular buyer actually pays, which can land above or below value depending on bargaining power, strategic motives, competing offers, finance and the synergies that buyer expects. A mainland group wanting a foothold in Tasmania may pay above market value to gain a ready-made team and customer base, while a rushed or forced sale often settles below it. A certified valuation gives you a benchmark to measure any offer against, and tells you when to accept and when to walk away.
Plan on a new valuation every two or three years, and sooner after any material change: a sharp shift in earnings, a big customer won or lost, a change of ownership, a new product or market, a large capital project, disruption in the industry or a transaction on the horizon. A business with an active employee share scheme needs a current value at each grant or taxing point under Division 83A, which can mean an annual update. A stale valuation is risky because people make decisions on it, and lenders, regulators and the other side of a deal will not accept it.
Sometimes, but not automatically. A full Valuation Engagement under APES 225 and IVS can serve several purposes at once, such as CGT, an ESS grant, succession planning and a finance application, provided the standard of value and the valuation date suit each one. A market value opinion prepared for the ATO cannot, though, be reused as a fair value measurement under AASB 13 for your auditor. Narrower engagements, whether limited in scope or confined to agreed procedures, can only be used for the purpose stated in the engagement letter. List every intended use at the start so the scope and standard of value cover them all.
Raise it with the valuer. Where you believe a fact is wrong or relevant information was overlooked, the valuer should look again and fix any genuine error at no cost to you. What the valuer cannot do is move the figure because you hoped for a different one, since that independence is what gives the report its weight. In a contested matter the usual step is a second opinion: your lawyer can engage another certified valuer to review the report, and in the Supreme Court of Tasmania or the Federal Circuit and Family Court the experts may be directed to confer and prepare a joint report showing where they agree and where they differ. That process usually narrows the gap.
13
Advanced Valuation Topics
Loss-making and early-stage companies, personal and enterprise goodwill, family groups of trusts and companies, layered share capital and valuations that cross borders.
A business that loses money can still be worth a good deal if it owns saleable assets, intellectual property or a customer base, or has a believable path back to profit. Which method applies depends on why the business is losing money. If they reflect deliberate investment in growth, a DCF that maps the path to profitability fits. If buyers would acquire the business for its customers, revenue multiples from comparable deals apply. If the losses look structural, the asset approach sets the floor, and for a start-up the venture capital and milestone methods replace earnings-based ones altogether. Whatever the method, the report has to be candid about how likely the assumed recovery is.
Personal goodwill attaches to an individual through their reputation, relationships and skill, while enterprise goodwill belongs to the business and can be sold with it. The difference matters in two places. In a family law property settlement, the Federal Circuit and Family Court asks whether the goodwill could be sold with the business or would leave with the practitioner; goodwill that cannot be sold may carry little weight as property, though it can still support that person's earning capacity. In a sale, buyers pay only for what transfers, so personal goodwill is handled through restraints of trade, handover periods and earn-outs. In Hobart, where many practices and trades are known by the owner's name, this question comes up often.
The valuer works entity by entity, then steps back to deal with the structure that ties them together. Each trading entity is valued on the method that suits it, since an operating company and a property-holding trust need different treatment. Non-operating assets at the top, such as real property, investments and surplus cash, are added at market value. The valuer then deals with structural effects: intercompany loans and charges to eliminate, transfer pricing that shifts profit between entities, tax embedded in unrealised gains, and any discount a buyer would apply for complexity. Many Tasmanian family businesses sit across discretionary trusts and companies built up over decades, so the structure is mapped before any valuation starts.
The option pricing method splits total equity value among the classes of securities in a company with a layered capital structure, such as ordinary shares, preference shares carrying liquidation preferences, options and convertible notes. Each class is treated as a call option on the company's value, with strike prices set by the preferences that rank ahead of it, and a Black-Scholes or binomial model allocates value between them. A backsolve runs the other way: it takes the price an investor paid for one class in a recent round and infers what the whole company, and so its ordinary shares, must be worth. Auditors and ESS valuers favour it because it anchors the result to a real transaction.
A cross-border valuation adds several layers. Forecasts are prepared in the functional currency and translated consistently; a country risk premium is added to the discount rate for offshore operations; accounting rules differ, so AASB-based figures must be reconciled with the other jurisdiction's; transfer pricing affects where profit shows up; and different tax systems change after-tax cash flows. The Australian signatory still works under APES 225, the report usually follows IVS so both sides recognise it, and an overseas standard may apply as well. Tasmanian exporters of seafood, wine and specialist marine equipment meet these issues regularly, and an overseas buyer may also need foreign investment approval.